Alicia 'Ali' Holt
New member
I recently got a 9 week old male shiba inu/border collie cross puppy. He's got the looks of a shiba inu and the personality of a border collie. One problem is his whining. I'm strict but loving with him. So I never give in to it. But he whines when he's in the crate all the time. I give him a treat, piece of clothing that smells of me, blanket that smells of his mum and a small cuddle. If I ignore him he gives in after a while. But I was wondering, when he whines should I tell him in a loud voice "NO" or should I just completely ignore him? When did your puppy stop whining?