2009 Toyota Corolla S vs. XRS trim?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Britny
  • Start date Start date
B

Britny

Guest
I'm planning on purchasing a 2009 Toyota Corolla. I have two questions:

1) I cannot decide between the S or the XRS trim. The only differences engine-wise are the liter capacity (1.8 for the S, 2.4 for the XRS) and 26 horsepower (132 for the S, 158 for the XRS). Both vehicles have 4-cylinder engines, and leather seats are available on both trims. Does anyone else know of any advantages/disadvantages of either? I would prefer information from current owners if possible.

2) I'm also wondering if automatic or manual transmission would serve me better? Both offer identical city/highway MPG, and the only advantage I can think of is that I've heard that automatics tend to be more reliable because they don't suffer from operator errors.

Thoughts?
Also,

The XRS has a 5-speed AT, while the S has a 4-speed AT.
Does this matter?
Also,

The XRS has a 5-speed AT, while the S has a 4-speed AT.
Does this matter?
Also,

The XRS has a 5-speed AT, while the S has a 4-speed AT.
Does this matter?
Haha.

Sorry about that...
 
well, the carolla is a pretty boring car to drive. you might as well go for the xrs to make it a bit more entertaining. it still won't handle well, and the interior will still be dull, but at least it will be a bit more powerful. yes, a 5 speed is much more desirable because it usually yields a higher top speed, and quicker acceleration because the gear ratios are better.

but personally i wouldn't even get a carolla. look into the subaru impreza. it has 4wd grip, it handles exceptionally, and the engine is very nippy. plus, it can come in hatchback form for added practicality. and because it's a subaru, it will run for hundreds of thousands of miles without any problems just like the toyota will.

but if for whatever reason you absolutely must have the carolla, get the xrs to make a dull car a bit more interesting.

but please consider the impreza too if you didn't already look into it. i guarantee that once you test drive it, you'll love it.

whatever your decision, good luck!

EDIT: what you heard about automatics are false. manuals are much more reliable, are more fun, and if you shift correctly, will yield better mpg.

if you live in a city and plan to be stuck in traffic a lot, don't get the manual though. it could ware out your leg pushing down on the clutch while being stationary. make sure the clutch is light before buying it.

good luck once more!
 
Back
Top