Both are great cars, but it boils down to what's more important for you. The Civic will have a lower ownership cost...it's cheaper, a little more reliable, and gets way better gas mileage (30 vs. 24). It will also hold its value somewhat better, if past indicators hold true. The 6 will obviously be larger, be roomier and more comfortable, and will have more power. Which fits your life better? That's your answer. Good luck.