Roger has not won a slam title since Australian Open 2010. Which to be fair is not really that long ago.
Federer has still been consistent @ the slams
FO '11 - Runner-Up
Wim '11 - 1/4 final
UO '11 - 1/2 final
AO '12 - 1/2 final
FO '12 - 1/2 final
So, clearly Feds is still part of the elite...
Obviously Dave is safe. Rachel was clear favourite to get the boot, but after JohnJames tantrums over not doing task yeasterday things might change. Also, JohnJames doesn't seem to defend Josie against Sam at all. IMO, Rachel is not that bad.
As he's only 23 maybe taking into account number of GS he's already won, would still hold him in good stead when considering whether he 1 of the greatest.
I think he will win about 18 slams by the time he retires. And that will include 5 or 6 more French Opens.